Tuesday, May 27, 2008

What Kind of People Does High Stakes Testing Make Our Students Into?

I’ve just finished reading an excellent doctoral dissertation by Steven Van Zoost. Van Zoost is a secondary teacher in Nova Scotia and he is about to complete a doctoral program at the University of South Australia. The evidence from his dissertation is that Steven is a good and caring teacher who relies on authentic assessment to gauge student progress in his classroom. While he is committed to authentic assessment, his dissertation asks: what kind of people do authentic assessment practices make his students into?

This is a question we might well ask about the assessment practices that dominate in the United States. What kind of people do high stakes achievement tests make our students into? We might also wonder what kind of people these sorts of assessments make teachers into.

Arguably, testing practices in this country make students into winners and losers. No matter how well students learn, no matter how hard they work, some students will fail relative to their peers. NCLB may include the goal that all students pass state achievement tests by 2014 but this doesn’t mean that we expect all children to achieve at the same level. In the end, we identify the best students in terms of the failures of other students. If everyone was successful, we wouldn’t know who was “the best.” This is the real worry about grade inflation. There aren’t enough failures.

To the degree that high stakes tests lead to teach-to-test curriculum, these assessment practices construct students as empty vessels to be filled with skills and facts that will be on the test. Students may (or may not) do better on the tests, but they aren’t better readers and writers, for example.

The emphasis on skills and facts that will be on the test also turns students, even kindergarteners, into little workers who have no time for recess or frills like art and music. The push to full day kindergarten and extended school days are based on the assumption that too much unstructured free time diminishes learning. This affects not only the learning identities of individual children, but also the meaning of childhood.

High stakes testing is turning many teachers, particularly those working in underperforming schools, into highly stressed technicians who are pressured into putting test scores above meaningful student learning. Nichols and Berliner (2007) indicate the enormous pressure of high stakes testing is also turning at least some teachers (and administrators) into cheaters.

Resistance to the narrow range of teaching and learning identities made available in high stakes testing environments is turning many teachers into “former teachers” and many students into “dropouts.”


Patricia said...

one of the toughest challenges i face in my teaching of an initial reading course for preservice teachers is dialogue around the hidden messages sent by the testing culture to young children - how do these messages shape children's purposes for learning? how do these messages interfere with children's ability to handle complex ideas or prepare them to develop initiative and thoughtful participation in intellectual life?
preservice teachers in my classes see my "point" they say but many quickly revert to a hierarchical vision of "basic skills" as a priority over complex instruction...especially at the end of the semester when they begin to prepare (and panic) for taking the teaching "tests" -- often they claim to forget what they actually know about language and literacy in the anxiety over passing these tests! for example, during a final class this semester, no class members felt comfortable attempting to identify short and long vowel sounds when a first grader visiting our class asked for homework help.....luckily the first grader was able to help revive the group who realized that they do actually know this stuff....

Yvonne said...

High stakes testing has limited the curriculum and put people in boxes. True learning has been put on the back burner. At the expense of nurturing learning and learning, our students and teachers are being pounded and extortion is being used. Hey parents are being told that if the don't send their children to school on high stakes testing days, their school will loose money! If this isn't extortion, then what is.

And most importantly, high stakes testing certainly have made the Halliburtons of education incredibly rich. Follow the money.

In the meanwhile, our students circle bubbles and believe it or not many have dropped out if not physically than mentally and emotionally.

High stakes testing has not added value.

Yvonne Siu-Runyan

Anonymous said...

good morning people. I'm really into shoes and I had been digging as far as something that exact make. The prices seeking the boots are about 250 dollars on every site. But for all I base this location selling them as a remedy for half price. I really want those [url=http://www.shoesempire.com]prada sneakers[/url]. I will probably order those. what is your opinion?

Anonymous said...

Hello. And Bye.

Anonymous said...


Quality assurance is implemented at the schematic design stage. Mansour Engineering’s quality assurance is an inclusive review of each discipline as well as an overall discipline coordination. Quality assurance procedures include analysis of the worst case scenario for verification of specific design parameters and for each discipline’s task. Project management overview integrates schedule and cost control into each and every aspect of design. Mansour Engineering project management objective is to develop a design that satisfies all requirements and is economically feasible to construct. To that end, cost estimating is within the preview and capabilities of each discipline project leader. Without sacrificing quality control or cost control, Mansour Engineering understands that scheduling is of the utmost importance. Mansour Engineering prepare a detailed timeline for each item on the project deliverable list and proceed on schedule by adjusting manpower activity to finish on time.

[url=http://www.mansour.ca] click here to go to Mansour Engineering[/url]


Anonymous said...

I cialis soft , cialisforsalecialiscostyub.com , cialis , free viagra , viagra prescription , viagra reviews

Anonymous said...

gotowkowa pozyczka
pożyczka bez bik
chwilówki zamość
pożyczki pozabankowe gdzie
nasz adres oraz kontakt
pożyczka bez bik bez bik
chwilówki bez dochodu